The Australian wealth industry is currently navigating a complex landscape, starkly highlighted by the government's recent Sustainable Finance Strategy Consultation paper. This initiative underscores an aggressive push towards Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing. However, emerging trends suggest a disconnect between this governmental push and the current sentiments of consumers and financial advisers, particularly against the backdrop of a burgeoning cost-of-living crisis.
A recent survey of 2,100 Australians by Adviser Ratings revealed that only 38% are considering ESG factors in their investment decisions. This figure is indicative of a broader sentiment shift among consumers, who are increasingly prioritising immediate financial stability and long-term wealth protection over ESG considerations in a cost-of-living crisis.
Chart 1 - Does ESG Come Into Consideration When Investing?
Source: Adviser Ratings
Further emphasising this dichotomy, advice practice heads across the country have reported a significant decrease in client enquiries about ESG investments. Last year, 45% of clients were enquiring about ESG-focused investment opportunities, a number that has dropped to 33% this year. This trend suggests a realignment of priorities among investors, spurred by the uncertainty that exists in the economic climate.
Financial advisers are witnessing firsthand the shifting priorities of their clients. "In the current economic environment, our clients are more concerned with wealth preservation and ensuring a stable retirement, rather than the nature of the investments generating their returns," noted one adviser, a senior financial adviser with more than $500M FUA based in Sydney. This sentiment is echoed by a Melbourne-based AMP adviser, who adds, "There's a palpable sense of ESG fatigue among clients. They feel overwhelmed by the constant push towards ESG investing, whether it's from the industry, affluent circles, or the younger generation."
The lack of a clear and unified understanding of what ESG investing entails further complicates the issue. Many consumers and advisers alike express confusion over the practical implications of ESG in investment strategies. This same adviser notes, "There's a disconnect between the concept of ESG investing and its practical application. Clients often don't have a clear idea of what it actually means for their portfolios."
This sentiment is indicative of a broader trend in the wealth industry. While the Australian government continues to advocate for sustainable finance and ESG investing, there's a growing need to align these initiatives with the immediate financial concerns and understanding of consumers. The industry faces the challenge of bridging this gap, balancing the push for sustainable investment with the prevailing economic realities and investor education on ESG.
As the Australian wealth industry continues to evolve, it will be essential to monitor how these trends develop, especially in light of the ongoing cost-of-living crisis and its impact on investment strategies. The key will lie in finding a balance that respects the immediate financial needs of consumers while promoting a broader understanding and integration of ESG principles in investment portfolios.
Article by:
Comments0